Skip to main content

THE LEGACY OF IBNU-TAYMIYAH

 Written By: Mohamed Abdifitah Mohamoud (AMEEN GUULED)

Date: September 06 2022.

 


Ibnu-Taymiyah was a great Islamic thinker and the founder of the so called salafi movement which is widely practiced in the gulf Countries and some other parts of the Islamic world, his doctrine of Islamic Understanding became more influenced among some Muslims in the late of 18th century after the Wahhabi movement emerged is Saudi Arabia.

He was born in Hernan turkey on 22 January 1263 and most of his life he lived in Damascus where he studied and flourished most of his life time.

Ibnu-Taymiyah become the most controversial Islamic scholar in his era because he harshly criticized many practices which were practiced by the main stream during his time.

In his life time he was arrested for several times, first time in 1306 after he was accused of Anthropomorphism (tajsim) which is the fact of stating physical attributes to God, he described that God has physical attributes, he also believed Muslims should accept the physical attributes God has assigned to himself in the Quran without without manification whereas his contemporary especially the theologies of Elmul-kalam like AL-ashariya believed God was incorporeal. Formless, he is outside time and space and not in the world or space  and ultimately God is beyond description, his first and second arrests were associated with the accusation of being corporeal and anthropomorphism.

In August 1309, Ibn-Taymiyah was taken into custody and placed under house arrest for seven months in the sultan's palace in Alexandria Egypt, He was later freed when al-Nasir Muhammad retook the position of sultan on 4th March 1310.


In 1310 he has written a fatwa that was about the validity and permissibility of making a journey to the grave of prophets and saints including the tomb of prophet Muhammad peace be upon him and he called this kind of practices an innovation and for this reason Ibnu-Taymiyah was again arrested in Damascus, He was very famous for opposing the ideas and the practices of intercession (Tabaruk) which is widely practiced in variety of Muslim countries till today

He was also arrested in 1320 for teaching against divorce orthodox whereby he rejected the validity of 3 divorce oaths in one setting he even believed if one divorce oath is uttered but not intended was not valid and not actual divorce

This was relief for the Muslim men in divorce oaths although till today it is not widely accepted by all Muslims and it is still a disputed topic.

 

Ibnu-Taymiyah called an innovation to anything that was not practiced by the prophet and his well guided predecessors, he categorized the customs of law into 3 categories

1.    The revealed law

2.    The interpreted law

3.    The adulterer law

1)    The revealed law is the law which is revealed by God and it is only found in the original scripted text of the Quran and Sunnah

 The interpreted law: is the law adopted by the 4 Islamic jurisprudence of Hanafi, Maliki, Shafi’I and Hambali

3)    The adulterer law:  which is the last law in Ibnu-Taymiya’s categories of custom laws contains anything that’s not the revealed and the interpreted law and he called them Innovation.

He blames Sufis to be responsible for all the innovations in the Islamic religion and that’s the reason he condemns the famous practices of Sufism like

     Dhikr: The act of gathering in circles while reciting some remembrance to Allah.

      Sama: The practice of listening and chanting with music for spiritual tranquility.

      Fanna/ Annihilation:  Experiencing the death of oneself and absorbing into the divine

  

He criticized the famous Muslim philosophers like Ibnu Arabi he opposed him for his famous ideology of “Wahdatul Wujud/ oneness” which he said it is making the Creator and the creation as one entity and for this act of opposing the most respected elites of Islam in his timeline and even before him made him a lot of enemies.

 Ibnu-Taymiyah also accused Imam fakhrudin razi of apostasy, polytheism and idle worship in his book ‘Bayan talbis aljahmiya’ 

After such multiple incidents whereby Ibnu-Taymiyah excommunicated some Sufi sheikhs, the leader of the Shadali Sufi order Ibnu Ada'ullah gathered a group of 500 people to protest against him and they both had a formal public debate.

Although one of the students of Ibnu-Taymiyah called Shams-Din al-Dahabi(d:1348) reported “Towards the end of his life, our teacher Ibn Taymiyya would state: ‘I do not deem anyone from among the Muslims to be an unbeliever.’” (Siyar A’lam al-Nubala’),

there are many incidents were Ibnu-Taymiyah himself declared Takfir or excommunicated some of his other fellow Muslims including Sufis and Shia, he also accused polytheism to the mangolis and ordered jihad against them in one of his fatwa’s.

Ibnu-Taymiyah Stated the following statement about the Alwaites who currently occupy 17.2% of the Syrian population

“They are heretics and apostates whose repentance cannot be accepted rather they should be killed wherever they are found and they may be cursed of what they are doing”.

Ibnu-Taymiyah also believed the destruction of the Mongols was a curse and punishment from the almighty God because the Muslims strayed and turned away from the righteous path that the prophet has left behind for them because the Sufis and Rationalists brought huge innovations into the revealed religion of Islam and that’s the main reason the writings and ideologies of Ibnu-Taymiyah were harsh and strict because he emphasized people to return to the right path and the source of knowledge should not be taken from the interpretations of the imams, rather he called the only source which is permissible to use is the original scripted text of the Quran and the Hadith.

For this reason, Ibnu-Taymiyah rejected the idea of TAQLIID which means imitation to a certain imam that you trust instead of going directly to original scripted source which can mislead you if you misunderstand it by your own perspective. 

 Instead of TAQLIID he emphasized the idea of IJTIHAD which is to strive to your best level of understanding of the original scripted text of the Quran and Hadith.

 For various reasons today all the terrorist groups in the world uphold the doctrine and the ideas of Ibnu-Taymiyah and they use him as their influencer they also call him ‘sheikh AL Islam’.

Salafism Wahhabism and the Takfir are contingent from the ideas of Ibnu-Taymiyah especially the idea of excommunicating fellow Muslims and calling Jihad against them especially against the Sufis and Shia.

 

Ibnu -Taymiyah left behind plenty of works which made him one of the most controversial figure in the late of medieval error, the following are some of his legacy

  •  Great compilation of fatw (MAJMU’UL FATAWI).
  • The rejection of the conflict between reason and revelation
  • Diseases of the Hearts.
  • Minhaj As-Sunnah an-Nabawiyyah
  • Al-Aqidah Al-Waasitiyyah.
  • Bayan Talbis Al‑Jahmiyyah

  

He died on 26 September 1328 at the age of 65, he died while he was in a jail in Damascus, thousands of people gathered for his funeral in Umayyad mosque, four funeral prayers offered on him, it is reported that two hundred thousand people gathered in his funeral and Ibnu kathir says in the history of Islam only imam Ahmad Ibnu Hanbal recieved such similar large crowd in his funeral , after his death his personal belongings were in high demand his skull cup was sold to 500 dirhams, he was buried in Damascus in ‘maqbara al sufiya (the cemetery of Sufis)’.

 

 I support his preference of IJTIHAAD over TAQLIID but I also blame him for the invention of the ideas of takfir(excommunication), in my opinion he was right about being strict and harsh about the innovations of new practices in Islam because after sometime passes those innovated practices can be misunderstood and it may stray people from the right path.

Allah knows the best. 

Popular posts from this blog

The Horn Of Satan

Written By: Mohamed Abdifatah Mohamoud (Ameen Guuleed)   Al-Shabaab is the most powerful terrorist group in the region of horn of Africa and their core principle is to rule Somalia under the Islamic sharia low by their interpretations, since Al-Shabaab was found they ruled by intimidating and terrifying. Every Somali authority’s priority is to eliminate Al-Shabaab since the election of president sheikh Sharif sheikh Ahmed.  Although Sharif succeeded in capturing more than 60 percent of the city from Al-Shabaab he didn’t do well in abstaining al-Shabaab from their malevolent desires of bombing and killing innocent people. Despite the efforts to eliminate Al-Shabaab they were growing in terms of wealth and intelligence, now most of the people believe some of major government officials are in cooperate with the terrorist group and that gives Al-Shabaab an access to the government resources directly and indirectly, Some of the government officials have direct link with al-Shabaab ...

Hiraab Dynasty / Yacquubi imamate

             somali sailors holding hiraab flag in Moqadishu,1860 The Rise            I n the early of 17 th century, the Ajuran empire which was ruling many parts in east Africa for almost 500 years encountered many strikes and setbacks from the locals especially from the local inhabitants in what is modern-day called Gal-gadud region of central Somalia which was also the indigenous place of the Ajuran empir e. The first clan to fight against or even oppose the Ajuran empire was Darandoole(Abgaal) clan who are commonly known as Abgaal a section of Hirab clan which comes under Hawiye Tribe as quoted by Lee V. Cassanelli in his book ‘the shaping of the Somali society’. “The Ajuuraan had decreed: “At the wells in our territory, the people known as Darandoolle (Abgaal) and the other Hiraab clans cannot water their herds by day, but only at night.” … Then all the Darandoolle gathered in one place. The leaders decided to...

From Prisoner to Minister

  Written by: Mohamed Abdifitah Mohamoud (Ameen Guuleed)    August 2, 2022 The new Somali prime Minister Hamze Abdi barre appointed Mukhtar  Robow as the Minster of Endowment and Religious affairs, Mukhtar Robow who is also known as Abu Mansur had a bounty of $5 million on his head and he was the second most important leader of the terrorist group Al-Shabaab, He defected from the group in 2017 after long unsolved dispute between him and his seniors including the formal leader of the group Ahmed Godane who was later killed by the US drones on September   2014 near the south coastal town of Barawe. Mukhtar Robow’s defection in 2017 was hailed and praised by the Somali government but later he was detained and was under house arrest since 2017 till h e was appointed as member of the Somali minister’s cabinet today, He was attacked in Baidoa by the Somali government forces a combined with Ethiopian Soldiers as per reports and after short time clashes between the ...